A factory of 1,200 workers, with the morning shift arriving in the 10 minutes before work: 120 people a minute through the gate. Anyone who has stood at a workers’ gate at 5:50 am knows that a little delay on each pass makes the whole line wait, and people who clock in late mean HR fixes the timesheet by hand again.
What one pass through a gate is made of
One pass has three parts: the person taps a card; the system checks the right to enter; the gate opens and the person walks through. The first and last parts depend on people and the type of gate. The middle part depends on the software, and that is the part people overlook when choosing equipment.
The specification of one high-speed gate maker gives a minimum of 25–30 people per minute per lane, and states that this depends on the access control system behind it. Technical literature on RFID card gates says a gate usually passes 40–60 people a minute when authentication is close to instant, but falls below 20 a minute if each pass waits 3 seconds for authentication.
Who decides to open: the controller or the server?
In many systems, the reader sends the card number to a server, the server looks up the rights and sends the open command back down. With a slow network or a server busy at exactly shift change, every pass gets one beat slower. The documentation of one access control software vendor compares two set-ups: when the controller at the door decides on its own, tap to unlock takes under 1 second; when the decision has to go through an intermediate device, it can take up to 51 seconds.
MSTAR Access takes the first route. Rights, shift schedules and rules are synchronised down to the controller at the door. A worker taps a card, the controller checks the rights and schedule and opens at once, and only then sends the event to the server. If the network drops mid-shift, the door still opens for the right people on the synchronised configuration. The same tap goes into the shift timesheet, with no file to export from a separate time clock.
The price of deciding at the door
No design comes free. When rights live in the controller, a change of rights only takes effect once it has been synchronised down. The same documentation notes that on an older version, revoking rights could take up to an hour to reach the controller. So when a vendor says a card is blocked in one action, ask the next question: how long until every door has received it?
With MSTAR Access, revoking all of a person’s rights is one action in the software. How long it takes to reach the controllers depends on the equipment; MSTAR engineers state that figure during the survey, before you sign.
Working out gate lanes for a shift change
Divide the people through the gate by the minutes of the shift change to get the flow. Divide by the capacity of one lane, round up, add 1 spare lane. A factory of 1,200 workers arriving in 10 minutes needs 120 people a minute; at 25 people a minute per lane that is 5 lanes, plus 1 spare makes 6.
The MSTAR Access page has a gate-lane calculator: enter the number of people and the minutes of the shift change to try it. Before choosing a gate and software, ask the vendor four questions:
- Does the controller decide to open on its own when the server connection is lost?
- After a change of rights or a blocked card, how long until every door has it?
- What is the capacity per lane measured with the access control system, in people a minute, not the gate’s own figure?
- Do card taps go straight into the timesheet, or do they need a file export?